How to spot a fake Black Friday deal

A new Groundwork Collaborative report found that nearly 1 in 3 Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals in 2024 and 2025 saved shoppers nothing. Here's how to check a price before you buy.

By the Dealizard team ·

Cartoon gecko examining a crossed-out red sale tag with a magnifying glass, next to a smaller green price tag in a night desert

A new investigation from Groundwork Collaborative looked at more than 350 products Amazon put on its own Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025. Nearly 1 in 3 of those "deals" were the same price or higher than in the month before the sale. Nearly 1 in 10 cost more.

The report, Deal or Decoy? Amazon's Deceptive Discounts, is about Amazon in the US. The same pricing tricks show up in other countries and at other retailers. This is what the researchers found, and how to check a deal before you buy.

What the report found

Groundwork compared each sale-event price with what the same product had sold for in the month leading up to Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Amazon's deal pages presented these offers as some of the "best" of the year. The Black Friday 2025 page said: "With so many deals to explore, we've handpicked some of the best ones you'll find."

Two examples from the report:

  • On Black Friday 2025, a pair of yellow Hunter women's short rain boots was listed as a deal at $126.99. Nine days earlier, the same boots had been $79.97. Waiting for the sale would have cost 59% more.
  • On Cyber Monday 2025, a pair of UGG Butte men's boots was listed as a deal at $179.98. About four weeks earlier, they had been $98.40, so the "deal" was 83% more than the recent low.

Among the deals that were worse than the recent price, the median sale-event price was 19% higher.

Groundwork calls on US regulators to require retailers to show the lowest price from the previous 30 days when they advertise a sale. In the EU, traders who announce a price reduction generally have to use the lowest price from the previous 30 days as the "prior price". That rule is Article 6a of the EU price indication rules, added by the Omnibus Directive.

The report also notes that, after learning of the study, Amazon removed the deal pages Groundwork used. The researchers published archived copies.

Why a "deal" can cost more

A sale only looks like a bargain if you compare it with a higher "was" price. If the price rises in the weeks before the sale, then comes back down, the discount can look bigger than it is. Sometimes the sale price is just the usual price, or higher than you could have paid a few weeks earlier.

A red "was" price or a countdown on its own does not tell you whether you're saving money.

How to check before you buy

  1. Ignore the "was" price and look at the actual price history.
  2. Check the lowest price from the last 30 days, and further back if you can. A genuine deal should be close to that recent low, not just cheaper than a brief spike.
  3. Paste an Amazon link into the Dealizard Deal Checker. It reads a year of prices and rates the deal Bad, OK, Good or Great. If the price was pushed up first, you'll see an inflated-price warning. It's free, and you don't need an account. It checks the price, not the product, so still read the reviews and look at the store before you pay.

Plenty of Black Friday prices really are the best of the year. Check first, then buy if today's price is close to the recent low.

Amazon's Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday run from 19 to 30 November 2026. For the confirmed sale dates this year, see Black Friday 2026: every confirmed sale so far. For a wider look at the research, including a UK Which? study, see Are Black Friday deals real?. More on the checker in Is it a real deal?.

Read the full report: Deal or Decoy? Amazon's Deceptive Discounts.

FAQs

How can I tell if a Black Friday deal is fake?

Look at the price history, not the "was" price. If today's price is the same as, or higher than, the lowest price from the last 30 days, it isn't a real saving. Paste an Amazon link into the Dealizard Deal Checker and it will rate the deal Bad, OK, Good or Great.

What did Groundwork Collaborative find about Amazon Black Friday deals?

Groundwork looked at more than 350 products on Amazon's own Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal pages in 2024 and 2025. Nearly 1 in 3 were the same price or higher than in the month before the sale, and nearly 1 in 10 cost more. The full report is Deal or Decoy? Amazon's Deceptive Discounts.

Why do prices go up before Black Friday?

A sale looks bigger if the "was" price is higher. Some prices rise in the weeks before a sale, then come back down, so the discount looks larger than the real saving.

What is a 30-day low price?

It's the lowest price a product sold for in the previous 30 days. Groundwork says retailers should show this when they advertise a sale. In the EU, traders who announce a price reduction generally have to use that 30-day low as the prior price.

How does the Dealizard Deal Checker work?

Paste an Amazon link into the Dealizard Deal Checker. It reads a year of prices and rates the deal Bad, OK, Good or Great. If the price was pushed up first, you'll see an inflated-price warning. It's free, and you don't need an account.

Do EU shops have to show the previous price?

Yes, in most cases. If a trader in the EU announces a price reduction, the prior price must generally be the lowest price from at least the previous 30 days. That comes from Article 6a of the EU price indication rules.

Are all Amazon Black Friday deals fake?

No. Groundwork's figures are about products Amazon featured on its own deal pages, and most of those still had a lower sale price than in the month before. Some Black Friday prices really are the best of the year. Check the history before you buy.

← More guides